What I wanted to do was create a screen that would open like a Dialog when something was clicked. Then the buttons would trigger an action for the item selected in the list. I knew I wanted to have this in a separate activity, but I wanted to have it display on top of the previous screen, like a dialog box.
android:theme="@android:style/Theme.Dialog"
I happened upon this answer, just put this in line into your Manifest file and the activity will have the style of a dialog! I think it makes the flow of the application much better when you have something that could have multiple actions you want to take, and you don't want to have to write excess code to accomplish. Applying different styles to individual activities in the manifest file has really improved the quality of my Android code.